Financial System

Does the Current Reliance on Credit Scores Deny Deserving Applicants?

Last week, we asked readers if credit scores were too much of a driver in home loan approval. You answered overwhelmingly that yes, credit scores prevent often worth applicants from […]

Last week, we asked readers if credit scores were too much of a driver in home loan approval. You answered overwhelmingly that yes, credit scores prevent often worth applicants from receiving loans, and that while scores can provide some useful information, they should not be the only tool in a lender’s tool box.

See selected reader comments at the jump, and then take this week’s poll: “Is there a third place in your community that serves as a cultural and social center?”

You said:

“Some borrowers have dinged credit scores due to one-time emergencies but could otherwise be good credit risks. Credit scores should be a factor in underwriting, but not one so primary as it is today.”

“Credit scores are an imperfect tool and there are good arguments to be made for additional flexibility. But ultimately, credit scores are still one of few tools that can be used to evaluate a person’s history.”

“Low credit scores are disproportionately located in communities of color and may reflect lack of access to opportunities to build good credit.”

“There is often inaccurate information on a credit report where a borrower could have a good payment history for several years but due to the seven-year requirement it could be years before a negative item is removed from that borrower’s credit report.”

Related Articles

  • Stock image of mobile phone lying on a corkboard with screen reading "Money Transfer" and fields for amount and account number (not filled in). A pair of white earbuds is connected to the phone and also lying on the cork.

    Colorado Wants to Give Tenants Money for Paying Rent

    June 20, 2024

    A new statewide program aims to help renters benefit from the value they add to the buildings they live in. Here’s how the program could work, and when it could begin.

  • Two parallel rows of massive columns, as of a courthouse or other official building, seen from one end. Perspective makes them appear to almost meet in the far distance.

    Are Race-Based Lawsuits Affecting Community Lenders?

    June 12, 2024

    Shelterforce spoke with community-lending leaders and experts about the current mood across the sector. What, if anything, are organizations planning to do to avoid becoming the next target?

  • A white man with light brown hair and beard in suit and tie stands at a lectern in front of a bright backdrop in shades of pink and lavender. The words "Just Economy" are printed in light blue as part of the abstract design. The visible part of the sign on the lectern front says "NCRC/National/Community."

    KeyBank and NCRC Are Back Together. What’s Different This Time?

    May 30, 2024

    The nonprofit is giving the big bank a shot at proving it’s not the “worst” for Black borrowers. But after getting burned by the lender during the last community benefits agreement, what guardrails can NCRC put in place to ensure KeyBank keeps its promises?