#164 Winter 2010-11 — TOD

Organizing for Inclusive TOD

Large-scale and small-scale transit-oriented development projects are popping up everywhere around the country, and in many places advocates are working to include affordable housing and other community priorities in the mix from the start.

Patrick Bennett Photography

The Village at Overlake Station, an affordable apartment complex integrated with a suburban bus station in Redmond, Wash.

Making the Case

The biggest step, perhaps, is making the case, and GCC spends a lot of its energy on that. In Antioch, Calif., GCC worked with the city and the city’s consultants to organize a public tour of the various potential sites within the planning process. From Pittsburg, they took people to see what “good developments” looked like from other parts of the region. From San Leandro, a city that was considering (and has since approved and developed) a downtown TOD project centered around a future bus rapid transit station and the San Leandro BART station, GCC organized a tour of affordable housing in Oakland. These outreach efforts, Hobson said, likely changed some hearts and minds.

In Antioch, for example, he says “We heard some things that bordered on the racist when it came to opposition to affordable housing. ‘I don’t want to live near those people,’ and that type of thing.” By the end of the tour, while those in opposition were not necessarily advocates, it was clear to all that affordable housing could be done well. GCC’s involvement helped usher a village plan that creates a land use and regulatory framework that allows up to 2,500 residential units, with at least 15 percent of that being affordable to

moderate-, low-, or very low-income households in line with state law, and 2.5 million square feet of commercial space. The affordability requirement would be met on a project-by-project basis, said Victor Carniglia, Antioch’s director of economic development. The city itself does not have an inclusionary housing requirement, but “it should not be hard to meet given the densities allowed and the relatively high median income levels in the census tract where the area is located,” he said. Getting approval for the plan, GCC’s Hobson said, could have been a “messy process” had it not been completely vetted by the community first.


  • Building in Affordability

    February 8, 2011

    A range of existing policy tools can help preserve and expand affordable housing near planned transit stations -- but to have the most effect, they need to be put in place up front.

  • An Affordable BeltLine?

    February 8, 2011

    The Atlanta BeltLine brings much promise to the city of Atlanta, but will elevated housing costs be an unwelcome addition? Atlanta is looking to a community land trust to preserve affordability for the long-term near this new asset.

  • Can Lease-Purchase Save Us?

    February 8, 2011

    As developers struggle to find buyers for rehabbed affordable homes, many are looking to a lease-purchase model to expand the pool of potential owners. But lease-purchase is far more complicated than just an end-run around the credit crunch.