#158 Fall 2009

The Painful Impact of the Housing Downturn on Low Income and Minority Families

The current downturn in housing has seized the markets, pushed home prices down further than any time in generations and has sparked the worst recession since the Great Depression. At the same time, nearly 18 million households are severely burdened with housing costs that consume over half their household incomes. While few have escaped the fury of the recent downturn in housing, tenant, low-income, and particularly minority, households have fared the worst.

Figure 1 Affordability Problems Surged During the Housing Boom

With the projected growth in minority households likely to be the greatest source of housing demand in the future, understanding the potential long-term effects of the housing downturn on minority house-holds is critical. Minorities have been especially hard hit by the current downturn. One significant factor is that minorities are more likely to have low household incomes, and low-income households have fared poorly.

Indeed, while one in five white households is low income, the rate for minority households is one in three. Low-income households are much more likely to face severe cost burdens. At last count in 2007, low-income households comprised over 13 million, or nearly three quarters, of the 17.9 million households paying more than half their incomes on housing. Additionally, low-income households accounted for half of the surge of over four million severely burdened households that occurred during the housing boom from 2001 to 2007 (Figure 1).

Even among low-income households, however, low-income minorities are more highly burdened than whites. While rates of severe burden for low-income whites rose from 39 to 43 percent from 2001 to 2007, minority rates increased from 50 to 54 percent. During this time, the number of severely burdened low-income white households grew by 857,000 (13 percent) but the number of severely burdened low-income minority households increased by fully 1.05 million (23 percent). Working at low-wage or part-time jobs is seldom enough to put an end to these severe affordability problems. In fact, employed workers head up roughly half of all severely cost-burdened households.

But minorities have also been hit especially hard by unemployment during the current downturn, increasing their housing affordability pressures. Unfortunately, the 5.8 million job losses resulting from the recession so far have also been concentrated among minorities. Going into the recession, unemployment rates for minorities were already higher than for whites. Whereas whites entered the recession with an unemployment rate of 4.4 percent, rates were 8.9 percent for blacks and 6.2 percent for Hispanics.

Figure 2 Even Controlling for Income, Foreclosures Are Markedly Higher in Minority Neighborhoods

With higher shares of younger householders more likely to be entry-level employees with little job security, minorities have been more susceptible to job loss and have felt a disproportionate share of the economic downturn. Now in the grip of the recession, as of April 2009, unemployment rates had risen to 15 percent for blacks, 11.3 percent for Hispanics, and 8 percent for whites.

About the Author

Daniel McCue

Daniel McCue is a senior research associate at the Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University.

Tags

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

OTHER ARTICLES IN THIS ISSUE

ISSUE TABLE OF CONTENTS

  • The Nitpicker’s Guide to Foreclosure Mitigation

    • Shelterforce Staff

    November 23, 2009

    First, it was judges like Justice Arthur M. Schack of the New York Supreme Court, who made waves by tossing foreclosure motions because he found a rising level of errors […]

  • Interview with Xavier de Souza Briggs, Associate Director for General Government Programs at the Office of Management and Budget

    • Matthew Brian Hersh
    • Harold Simon

    November 23, 2009

    Xavier de Souza Briggs, Associate Director for General Government Programs at the White House Office of Management and Budget has a portfolio that includes HUD, Treasury, Commerce, Justice, Transportation, and Homeland Security departments, as well as the U.S. Postal Service and Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. All of these make a direct and profound impact in the community development world.

  • A 21st Century Vision For Community Development

    • Joe Kriesberg

    November 23, 2009

    Today's economic crisis is devastating neighborhoods and households across the country. Urban, low-income communities that were slowly recovering from the disinvestment of earlier decades are now falling back to where they were in the 1970s. Rural communities, walloped by the collapse of key economic generators, have suffered no less. Families that had begun to break the cycle of poverty and build small amounts of savings are now being plunged back into debt. Yet, at a time when the work of community development corporations is more needed than ever, there are growing questions about their long-term viability and efficacy.